data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/05db2/05db235383527ee0baf02deaab55d29ad96a3547" alt="Maricopa county audit findings"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3a89b/3a89bebd2c8eba798d901c23f648f42fc1b3573f" alt="maricopa county audit findings maricopa county audit findings"
Tabulation machines and other parts of the county’s election management system are air-gapped, meaning they’re physically unable to be connected to other computer systems.Īnd claims deemed false were those that the audit team should have known were wrong, even with their lack of knowledge about elections. Two were, Jarrett said, but those were web servers that are supposed to be connected. Misleading claims were those which were technically true, but presented in a way that would lead people to a faulty conclusion, such as claims by CyFIR, one of the companies that was part of the audit team, that several pieces of equipment from the elections department were connected to the internet.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/76e56/76e56508ff2445cb2881044e80684f51615f32ff" alt="maricopa county audit findings maricopa county audit findings"
But the auditors reached that conclusion using commercial databases that are often inaccurate combined with partial information about voters, Jarrett said.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eba26/eba260a2c2b4b2827efea7c28478c574013e5885" alt="maricopa county audit findings maricopa county audit findings"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/18f40/18f4054b8b6b15044bedd145ba9b9e37d4d81d46" alt="maricopa county audit findings maricopa county audit findings"
For example, Cyber Ninjas claimed about 53,000 ballots were questionable because the voters’ addresses didn’t match up with voter registration records. Of the 75 claims that the audit team made, Scott Jarrett, Maricopa County’s director of election day voting, said the county’s analysis debunked all of them, finding 38 to be inaccurate, 25 to be misleading and 11 to be completely false.Ĭlaims were deemed inaccurate when the auditors used methodology that was either incorrect or faulty, or they simply lacked understanding of federal and state laws governing elections. “Now, it’s my hope that this is going to be the last word on the 2020 election because you’re going to hear the facts in detail.” “I wish that we were not still here discussing the 2020 election, but, unfortunately, the state Senate, working with their contractors, have decided to go through with a detailed process to come up with certain conclusions,” said Supervisor Bill Gates, the board’s chairman. Doug Logan, the company’s founder and the leader of the audit team, had promoted those false claims and had even actively participated in the “Stop the Steal” movement that attempted to legitimate those allegations and overturn President Joe Biden’s victory. She hired Cyber Ninjas despite the company’s lack of relevant qualifications or experience with election-related matters. The county also issued a 93-page report, titled “Correcting the Record: Maricopa County’s In-Depth Analysis of the Senate Inquiry,” on its findings.įann initiated the audit in response to the false claims that former President Donald Trump and many of his supporters spread that the 2020 election was rigged against him. Nearly every claim that Senate President Karen Fann’s so-called audit team made about the 2020 general election was either inaccurate, misleading or patently false, according to a long-awaited rebuttal by Maricopa County.Ĭounty officials have spent months since the audit team presented its findings in September examining the allegations, which included tens of thousands of possibly questionable votes, ballot tabulation equipment being improperly connected to the internet, illegally deleted files and early ballots being inappropriately counted despite missing signatures from voters.ĭuring a four-hour presentation to the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors and county Recorder Stephen Richer on Wednesday, members of the county’s elections team laid out a point-by-point refutation of the claims made by audit team leader Cyber Ninjas and other members of the team that spent six months hand-counting ballots, examining machinery and probing other aspects of the 2020 election.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/05db2/05db235383527ee0baf02deaab55d29ad96a3547" alt="Maricopa county audit findings"